Hawaii
Hawaii State Bar
DISCIPLINARY BOARD of the HAWAII SUPREME COURT
FORMAL OPINION NO. 34
Inquiry has been made regarding the ethical propriety of an attorney
arranging for a client to obtain loan financing to pay (a) the attorney's
fees, and (b) litigation expenses.
An arrangement whereby an attorney refers a client to a bank or other
lending institution to obtain a loan for legal fees and costs is generally
regarded as consistent with the attorney's duty to make legal services
available, thus preserving the integrity and independence of the legal
profession. In making such a referral, an attorney need not determine that
the credit arrangements are fair to the client or otherwise become involved
in such arrangements.
An attorney may provide substantial assistance in arranging financing for a
client to pay the attorney's legal fees and to pay litigation expenses
provided the following conditions are met: (a) the credit charges are not
usurious; (b) the client is fully informed as to the terms of the credit
arrangement; (c) if the attorney or law firm has a financial interest in the
lending institution or will gain financially in any way from the credit
arrangement, that fact is made known to the client in advance of the
client's application for financing, and (d) although an attorney is not
required to determine that the terms of a particular credit arrangement are
objectively fair to the client, the attorney should suggest that the client
consult with independent counsel for that determination. "Substantial
assistance" is defined as personal involvement in assisting and securing
financing, beyond the mere referral to a lending institution.
DATED: Honolulu, Hawaii, August 2, 1994.
JAMES A. KAWACHIKA, CHAIRPERSON, DISCIPLINARY BOARD GERALD H. KIBE, CHIEF
DISCIPLINARY COUNSEL
|
|